ATLANTIC OCEAN — Three weeks after 27-year-old Vermont resident Anna Kepner was found dead under still-unexplained circumstances aboard the luxury vessel Arcadia of the Seas, a second passenger has now disappeared from the exact same ship — and investigators are stunned by what connects them.
The missing passenger, identified as 44-year-old software consultant David Harlan, vanished during the ship’s return voyage. His cabin was found completely untouched, with his wallet, passport, and phone still inside — but one object was missing:
the same personal item Anna was known to have on her when she was last seen.
Authorities have not disclosed what that item is, but multiple sources say it is “highly specific and deeply significant.”
“This is not random — we are dealing with a pattern,” one federal investigator told reporters. “Both cases now appear linked by intent, opportunity, and something neither of them should have had.”
THE CREEPY CONNECTION
Documents obtained by reporters reveal that although Anna and Harlan did not know each other, they:
-
booked the cruise on the same day
-
paid using the same online travel agent
-
were assigned cabins on the same deck
-
both requested no housekeeping for the duration of the voyage
-
and both had their onboard key cards used after they were last seen alive
But the most unsettling detail?
Both passengers had reportedly been researching the same online forum thread, described by investigators as “conspiracy-adjacent and highly encrypted,” days before boarding.
THE SHOCKING DETAIL AT SEA
The ship’s captain confirmed late last night that dive teams searching the waters below Harlan’s last known location found a piece of clothing matching Anna Kepner’s size and brand — despite her body having been removed from the ship weeks ago.
It was located twelve nautical miles from the point where Harlan vanished.
“There is no rational chain of custody that explains how that item got there,” said a maritime forensic analyst. “Unless someone carried it back onto the ship — after Anna was already dead.”
CREW MEMBERS ARE STARTING TO TALK
A staff member who asked not to be named told reporters that security footage from the lower deck was “tampered with” the night Anna died.
Another insisted they overheard two officers arguing about something that “should have been locked in the restricted cargo hold.”
INVESTIGATION EXPANDS TO LAND
The FBI and Coast Guard are now conducting a joint investigation that includes:
-
Hidden phone recovered in Anna’s cabin
-
Passenger list cross-matching
-
A possible third person who has not been publicly named
-
The mysterious item missing in both cases
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The ship is being held in port under federal order. All crew and remaining passengers are being re-interviewed, and authorities are reportedly considering the possibility of a coordinated extraction or staged disappearance.
One agent stated bluntly:
“This isn’t a coincidence. It’s a message.”
