UNTAMED: Season 2 Plot Twist Could Change Everything — Kyle Turner Faces Firing Over a Serious Love Mistake

Netflix’s Untamed is gearing up for its second season, set to premiere on October 3, 2025, with a new national park, a fresh mystery, and a seismic plot twist that could redefine Kyle Turner’s journey. After a debut season that topped Netflix’s charts with 24.6 million views in its first week, the crime drama returns with Eric Bana as ISB agent Kyle Turner, diving into a case tied to the park’s founding family and a missing hiker. A shocking revelation suggests Kyle could face being fired over a “serious love mistake,” threatening his career and unraveling his personal life. With Elizabeth Debicki’s enigmatic character at the heart of this twist, Season 2 promises to push Kyle to his limits. This 1,000-word article explores the potential plot twist, its implications, and why it could change everything for Untamed.

A New Park, A New Crisis

Season 1 of Untamed, released on July 17, 2025, saw Kyle Turner unravel the death of Lucy Cook in Yosemite National Park while grappling with the loss of his son Caleb, his divorce from Jill Bodwin (Rosemarie DeWitt), and struggles with alcoholism. The season ended with Kyle leaving Yosemite, emotionally battered but with closure, setting the stage for Season 2’s new national park. Co-showrunners Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith have teased a setting that will make Kyle “very uncomfortable,” distinct from Yosemite’s familiar terrain, with speculation pointing to parks like Yellowstone or Glacier.

The central mystery involves a missing hiker, whose chilling voice recording in episode 3 leads Kyle to the park’s founding family and a family landmark tied to his past. This landmark—possibly a cabin or monument—connects to Kyle’s personal history, amplifying the stakes. The introduction of Elizabeth Debicki as a member of the founding family, whose appearance shocks Kyle, suggests she is the “one person he swore never to see again.” Her role is poised to trigger the season’s biggest twist: a love mistake that could cost Kyle his job.

The Love Mistake: What Could It Be?

The phrase “serious love mistake” implies a romantic misstep with professional consequences, a new angle for Kyle, whose Season 1 arc focused on grief and duty rather than romance. While Season 1 briefly mentioned a past fling with hotel manager Lana (Alexandra Castillo), Kyle’s emotional focus was on his ex-wife Jill and their shared loss. Season 2’s twist suggests a more significant romantic entanglement, likely involving Debicki’s character, given her pivotal role in shocking Kyle.

One possibility is that Debicki plays a former lover from Kyle’s past, perhaps from before his marriage to Jill or during a low point after Caleb’s death. This woman, now tied to the park’s founding family, could be linked to a scandal or ethical breach that jeopardles Kyle’s career. For instance, their past relationship might have involved a professional lapse—such as Kyle covering up a minor crime for her or bending ISB rules during an earlier case. If this history resurfaces during the hiker’s investigation, it could lead to an internal review, threatening Kyle’s position. Alternatively, the “love mistake” could be ongoing: Kyle might develop feelings for Debicki’s character while investigating the hiker’s case, compromising his objectivity and leading to a conflict of interest that risks his job.

Another theory ties the mistake to Jill. Season 1 revealed Jill’s secret: she hired Shane Maguire to kill Sean Sanderson, Caleb’s murderer, without Kyle’s knowledge, causing their divorce. If Debicki’s character is connected to Jill—perhaps a friend or relative who knows about the Sanderson plot—the “love mistake” could involve Kyle’s lingering feelings for Jill, leading him to protect her from legal consequences at the cost of his career. This scenario would align with the family landmark, possibly a place tied to Kyle and Jill’s past, like a cabin where they spent time with Caleb.

Elizabeth Debicki’s Role and the Founding Family

Elizabeth Debicki’s casting, with her proven ability to portray complex characters in The Crown and The Night Manager, suggests a multifaceted role. As a member of the park’s founding family, her character likely wields influence, perhaps as a historian, park official, or descendant guarding family secrets. The hiker’s voice recording, described as cryptic, may implicate the family in a cover-up—possibly environmental crimes, land disputes, or a historical scandal tied to the park’s establishment. Kyle’s shock at seeing her implies a personal history, making her the key to both the case and the love mistake.

If Debicki’s character is a past lover, their reunion could rekindle old feelings, complicating Kyle’s investigation. For example, she might manipulate Kyle to protect her family’s legacy, leading him to overlook evidence or make decisions that violate ISB protocol. Alternatively, she could be an antagonist, using their shared history to undermine Kyle, exposing his past mistake to force his dismissal. Her role in episode 3, where the hiker’s recording triggers a confrontation, will likely reveal the nature of their connection and the mistake’s consequences.

Implications for Kyle’s Career and Arc

Kyle being fired would be a dramatic shift from Season 1, where he was suspended for punching Shane Maguire but retained his job. A “serious love mistake” severe enough to cost his career suggests a breach of ethics, such as fraternizing with a suspect or falsifying reports. This aligns with the showrunners’ intent to put Kyle “on his back foot,” stripping away the confidence he had in Yosemite. Losing his job could force Kyle to confront his identity outside the ISB, deepening his arc of redemption and self-discovery.

The twist also ties to the season’s themes of legacy and accountability. The founding family’s influence mirrors Kyle’s personal history, with the landmark symbolizing unresolved trauma. If Kyle’s love mistake involves protecting someone—whether Debicki’s character or Jill—it could echo Season 1’s moral ambiguity, where Jill’s actions blurred the line between justice and vengeance. This parallel would challenge Kyle to reconcile his duty as an agent with his personal loyalties, potentially at the cost of his career.

What This Means for Season 2

The potential firing of Kyle Turner over a love mistake could reshape Untamed’s narrative. Without his ISB role, Kyle might investigate the hiker’s case as a civilian, adding stakes and tension. The involvement of Debicki’s character and the founding family suggests a conspiracy that could expose corruption within the park’s history, with Kyle’s personal and professional crises intertwining. Returning characters like Naya Vasquez (Lily Santiago) or Jill could anchor Kyle’s journey, though the new park likely introduces fresh faces.

The October 3, 2025, release, accelerated from Season 1’s timeline, reflects Netflix’s confidence in the show’s 80% Rotten Tomatoes rating and massive viewership. The park’s visuals—whether Yellowstone’s geysers or Glacier’s peaks—will amplify the story’s intensity, with cinematography capturing the wilderness’s beauty and danger.

Why This Twist Changes Everything

Untamed Season 2’s plot twist, with Kyle facing dismissal over a love mistake, promises to upend his world. Elizabeth Debicki’s role as a figure from his past, tied to the park’s founding family, adds emotional and narrative complexity. As Kyle navigates the hiker’s case and his own secrets, the threat of losing his job could force him to redefine his purpose. Premiering October 3, 2025, Untamed Season 2 will deliver a darker, more personal thriller, proving the wilderness is as untamed as the human heart.